Why Manchester United Now Want Scott McTominay Back?
When Scott McTominay left Manchester United for Napoli in 2024, few expected him to become one of Serie A’s brightest stars. Below you will see information about is news which has been summarized The Football Breakdown.
After 255 appearances for the Red Devils, he sought a fresh start in Italy and it paid off spectacularly. The Scottish midfielder thrived under Napoli’s attacking system, scoring 13 goals and helping the club win the Serie A title, his first major trophy.
McTominay’s leadership and work rate made him a fan favourite at the Stadio Diego Armando Maradona. His ability to drive forward from midfield and his improved goal threat earned him the league’s MVP award. The once-rotational United player was now one of Italy’s most admired midfielders.
Despite his success, reports suggest McTominay and his partner Cam Reading have felt somewhat unsettled in their second season. That uncertainty has opened the door for potential suitors — including a surprising one from his old home, Manchester United.
United’s Regret and Renewed Interest
Manchester United are reportedly reconsidering their 2024 decision to sell McTominay for £26 million. Now, to bring him back, they’d have to pay nearly double around £44 million. According to reports, United officials believe his departure was a “mistake,” given his form, versatility, and understanding of the club’s culture.
However, United are not alone in the race. Barcelona, Newcastle United, and Tottenham Hotspur have all been linked with the Scottish midfielder. His blend of energy, pressing, and late goal-scoring runs fits several systems, making him one of Europe’s most in-demand midfielders heading into 2025.
CaughtOffside reported: “There is concrete interest in Scott McTominay. Manchester United would have him back, and keep an eye on Newcastle and Tottenham. Barcelona also view him as a good fit.” For United, however, the interest is personal a chance to right a wrong.
Read Also: Juventus Risk Losing Rising Star to Arsenal, Chelsea or Real Madrid
Solskjaer’s Shock and Keane’s Warning
Former Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has openly questioned the decision to sell McTominay. On the Stick to Football podcast, he said he was “shocked” the club let him go, praising the midfielder’s mentality and leadership. “Scott gets the club,” he said. “He’s shown in Italy how good he is. You only know what he brings when he’s gone.”
Solskjaer highlighted that McTominay’s best qualities physicality, energy, and late attacking runs were often underused at United. He believes McTominay’s success in Italy is proof that he simply needed the right role to shine.
Not everyone agrees. Club legend Roy Keane cautioned that bringing McTominay back might not solve United’s deeper issues. “Good luck to the lad,” Keane said, “but I still wasn’t hanging my hat on him to bring United back.” His view reflects a split among fans about whether nostalgia should influence recruitment.
A Pricey Comeback or a Closed Chapter?
McTominay remains under contract with Napoli until 2028, and the Italian champions are in no rush to sell. He’s already scored four more goals this season across Serie A and the Champions League, showing no signs of slowing down. Napoli’s project still values him highly, making any potential transfer a costly one.
His growing connection with teammates like Rasmus Højlund another former United player and Kevin De Bruyne has strengthened Napoli’s midfield further. Unless a massive offer arrives, the club will likely resist interest.
Still, Manchester United’s admiration hasn’t faded. McTominay’s success abroad highlights what they lost a disciplined leader with a relentless engine. Whether the Red Devils can bring him back or not, his rise in Italy serves as a reminder that sometimes, a player must leave home to prove his true worth. Follow footballtipsonline.co.uk for weekly deep dives into football’s biggest stories.
